If you haven’t noticed, I have a lot of felt projects on my blog. I really love felt. So far, I’ve just been using acrylic felt from the craft store because it’s cheap, and honestly I didn’t know very much about the other options. It’s fine to use for things that won’t be touched much, but for toys or things that are going to be shoved into the bottom of a dress up bin, I wanted to find a better option. Everything I’ve made is still holding up just fine, but I hate the way that the felt pills or fuzzes when it’s handled a lot.
I got several different samples of felt to play around with so I could decide what kind I liked the most. I tried out a 100% wool, a wool/rayon blend, a polyester “eco” felt made from recycled plastic, and just the craft store acrylic (also made from plastic) to compare. I took each of my felt samples, embroidered on them, cut them, pulled them, rubbed them, and crumpled them. And no, I was not being very scientific when I did my “tests”.
You can’t really see much with my horrible photography skills. In the end, all of them pilled (fuzzed). Surprisingly the wool/rayon blend seemed to pill the least. The acrylic, as expected, pilled the most. When I tested their strength by cutting off strips and pulling, the 100% wool performed the best, the acrylic was the worst, the polyester and the wool/rayon blend were about the same in the middle.
I wanted to take into account not only the durability, but also the cost of the felt. Although 100% wool is very nice and supposed to be the best, it’s super expensive. Not really worth the cost since the other options seemed fine to me. Just my opinion of course. The polyester felt is definitely a lot nicer than the acrylic, and I do like that it’s made from recycled plastic. The price is really great too…in the end, however, I decided that I like the wool/rayon blend made by National Nonwovens the best. There’s something about the wool felt that gives it a warm, not shiny, feeling. I also really love that it is manufactured right here in the USA. I like that I’m supporting a US based company. It’s reasonably priced, and they have some really beautiful colors to choose from. The deciding factor for me was the way the fabric pilled the least when I handled it a lot. I’ve been using it to make birthday crowns for my etsy shop, and I love it!
I wrote this post, not because I want to advertise a product to you, but because I really want you to know that there are other options out there besides the craft store. I am not currently affiliated with National Nonwovens, although I would love to be! To see all of the colors laid out, I recommend going to the manufacturer’s website here. I really LOVE this product, and I will be using it for a lot (if not all) of my felt crafts from here on out. Hope this helps someone out there!
Options for buying:
-Joann’s usually has a VERY limited selection of colors of this brand (mostly earth tones).
-Go straight to the manufacturer’s website to buy large quantities at wholesale prices.
-National Nonwoven’s online store, commonwealthfelt.com, lets you buy smaller quantities.
-Sometimes I order from Prairie Point Junction. They have great customer service and you can order as much or as little as you like.
-There are a few sellers on Etsy who are selling National Nonwoven’s felt. Type the name in the search bar to find them. I always like to support fellow Etsy sellers!